The fteval Journal for Research and Technology Policy Evaluation

The fteval Journal for Research and Technology Policy Evaluation aims to position itself at the interface between research and technology policy practice and academic quality, thereby contributing to the exchange between the various stakeholder groups in the field of RTI evaluation. Thematic issues alternate with thematically open ones. Including the previous newsletters from which the journal emerged, 56 issues have been published so far. The fteval Journal is published as open access. Each article is subject to an editorial review. Information for authors can be found on the following page: https://fteval.at/en/for-authors/

Calls for Papers

Issue #58 is a special issue jointly created with FORWIT about science for policy, advisory councils and evaluation. We collect abstracts until end-July.
Call for Contributions [PDF]

Issue #59 (Publication from 2026) is thematically open. Submission and publication are possible on an ongoing basis.

Pilot for open review

Issue #59, which covers a range of topics, will be reviewed as a pilot project using the ‘open peer review’ method. The process is inspired by the MetaROR network.

Previous issues

All previous issues of the fteval Journal for Research and Technology Policy Evaluation can be accessed here: Previous issues

Current issues

18 articles constitute the newest issue #57, the Proceedings of the REvaluation Conference 2024:

Table of Contents

  1. Editorial: Science, Policy, and Advice. Lasting Tensions in a Symbiotic Relationship
    Pichler, Rupert, König, Thomas, Buntfuß, Paul, Wagner, Isabella
    Pages: 7-28
  2. A Brief History of Science and Research Policy Advisory Councils in Austria
    Pichler, Rupert
    Pages: 30-55
  3. Independent Advice in Research and Innovation Policy: The Role of the Spanish Science, Technology and Innovation Advisory Council (CACTI)
    Banda, Enric, Sanz-Menéndez, Luis
    Pages: 56-81
  4. Evidence-Based Policy Advice? The German Council of Science and Humanities
    Heinze, Thomas, Jappe, Arlette
    Pages: 82-104
  5. Quality Management in Science Advice. A Practice Report
    Buntfuß, Paul, König, Thomas
    Pages: 105-123
  6. Science for Policy in Austria - A Survey of Expert Councils and Their Areas of Responsibility
    Faßmann, Heinz
    Pages: 125-147
  7. The Servant of Two Masters. Scientific Policy Advice: The Establishment of a National Scientific Advisory Network in Switzerland - A Field Report.
    Zollinger, Lukas
    Pages: 148-175
  8. Knowledge for Place-Based Policymaking: Towards Interactive Science-For-Policy Ecosystems
    Wise, Emily, Wilson, James, Schwaag Serger, Sylvia
    Pages: 176-209
  9. Science, Technology and Innovation Policymaking, Advice and Evaluation Capabilities in Post-Apartheid South Africa: An Assessment
    Kahn, Michael, Ralphs, Gerard, Mustapha, Nazeem, Borel-Saladin, Jacqueline
    Pages: 210-252
  10. The Evolution of Scientific Advice in EU Institutions.
    Allegra, Alessandro
    Pages: 253-278

How much independence does scientific policy advice need – and how much can it afford? When does evidence become a political argument, and when does expertise remain without consequence? This special issue brings together contributions from Austria, Germany, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, South Africa and the EU that get to the bottom of these questions – historically, institutionally and systemically. At its centre are advisory councils and evaluation systems: their origins, their evolution, and their often contradictory roles at the interface of science and politics. The findings are as sobering as they are illuminating: neither maximum autonomy nor close alignment with the political process guarantees impact. What remains is the need to continuously recalibrate this balance – and that is precisely what this issue sets out to explore.

The special issue #58 - Governing with Evidence. Councils, Advisory Sytems, and Evaluation was created together with the FORWIT and co-edited by Rupert Pichler and Thomas König. Thank you very much for this cooperation!